Learning Goals & Products

Learning Goals

1

Students will be able to analyze archival maps, laws, advertisements, records, photographs, artwork, and firsthand accounts to explain how economic, political, legal, and cultural forces reinforced racial power from Reconstruction through the Harlem Renaissance.

2

Students will be able to compare African American perspectives on racial violence, legal exclusion, migration, urbanization, institution-building, cultural continuity, and resistance to explain how circumstances shaped different experiences and responses.

3

Students will be able to evaluate the credibility, perspective, limitations, and silences of diverse Schomburg Center sources to determine what evidence can support interpretations of power, resistance, and cultural continuity.

4

Students will be able to synthesize historical evidence and information about BYP100’s organizing challenge to define how trust, communication, access, risk, and shared decision-making affect collective action across different times and New York City neighborhoods.

5

Students will be able to design and justify accessible exhibit labels, visual displays, and a practical organizing recommendation to communicate evidence-based connections among power, resistance, cultural continuity, and present-day collective action.

6

Students will be able to revise historical interpretations and public-facing products in response to peer and partner feedback to demonstrate ethical collaboration, reflective decision-making, and responsibility to represented communities.

Products

individual

BYP100 Historical Interpretive Brief and Exhibit Label Prototype

Each student produces a source-cited brief comparing historical barriers to Black collective action from Reconstruction through the Harlem Renaissance with BYP100’s current coordination challenges, proposes a practical recommendation, and includes a prototype exhibit label and visual. The student documents source limitations, audience needs, feedback, and evidence-based revisions.

team

Schomburg Public History Exhibit Label Set and BYP100 Partner Briefing

Teams synthesize members’ research into a revised public-facing label set and digital visual display explaining a key connection among power, resistance, and cultural continuity, then deliver a partner briefing that applies the history to BYP100’s organizing challenge. The presentation uses cited evidence, multiple perspectives, audience feedback, and a justified recommendation for strengthening collective action.

Rubric
Mastery-Based Rubric Standards-first rubric
Category
Standard
Beginning (1)
Developing (2)
Proficient (3)
Exceeding (4)
New York
A.9-12.7 - Create meaningful and persuasive understandings of the past by fusing disparate and relevant evidence from primary and secondary sources and drawing connections to the present.
  • I can identify a limited set of source details about power, resistance, and cultural continuity, but my connections between sources are often unclear, incomplete, or only partly accurate
  • I may describe the present-day organizing challenge in a general way, yet my claim and exhibit or brief do not consistently use evidence to explain how historical and current barriers are connected.
  • I can use several relevant sources to explain how economic, political, legal, and cultural forces worked together to shape Black life and resistance, and I can make a basic connection to BYP100’s organizing challenge
  • My labels or brief include some evidence and a clear central idea, but my reasoning, comparison of perspectives, or recommendation may still need more specificity, accuracy, or audience awareness.
  • I can fuse evidence from diverse primary and secondary sources to build a clear, persuasive interpretation of how interconnected systems of power shaped barriers to Black collective action from Reconstruction through the Harlem Renaissance and how those barriers resemble or differ from challenges facing BYP100 today
  • I can support my exhibit labels or interpretive brief with accurate evidence, explain multiple perspectives, and revise my work using feedback to improve clarity, credibility, and fit for the intended audience.
  • I can strategically select, synthesize, and cite varied evidence to construct a nuanced and compelling public history argument that explains how systems of power endure and how people resist by disrupting those connections
  • I can compare multiple perspectives, address limitations or silences in the sources, and use clear communication and digital or visual design to produce polished exhibit labels and a partner-ready brief that offer a practical, evidence-based recommendation for collective action and demonstrate thoughtful revision after feedback.
New York
A.9-12.2 - Identify, describe, and evaluate evidence about events from diverse sources (including written documents, works of art, photographs, charts and graphs, artifacts, oral traditions, and other primary and secondary sources).
  • I can identify a few sources and describe basic details about what they show about power, resistance, and Black life, but my evidence may be incomplete or loosely connected
  • I need support to explain how the sources relate to the historical question and to the present-day organizing challenge.
  • I can describe and compare several diverse sources, including what each source suggests about economic, political, legal, cultural, or social conditions
  • I can use some evidence to make a clear connection between Reconstruction through the Harlem Renaissance and a current organizing barrier, though my reasoning may still rely on generalizations or miss important limitations.
  • I can evaluate evidence from multiple source types and explain how different perspectives shape the historical record
  • I can connect relevant evidence into a persuasive claim about barriers to trust, communication, access, risk, or decision-making, and I can use source credibility, limitations, and context to support a practical recommendation for action.
  • I can strategically select, synthesize, and evaluate diverse sources to build a nuanced and persuasive interpretation that explains how interconnected systems of power affected Black communities and how people resisted and built institutions
  • I can compare perspectives, address limitations and counterevidence, and communicate a clear, audience-ready argument or exhibit that connects the past to BYP100’s present-day challenge with specific, well-supported recommendations.
New York
11-12SL5 - Make strategic use of digital media and/or visual displays in presentations to enhance understanding of findings, reasoning, and evidence, and to add elements of interest to engage the audience.
  • I can identify a few relevant visual or digital elements for my exhibit label set or brief, but my connections to evidence, audience, and the project’s historical focus are limited, uneven, or partly unclear
  • I may need significant support to explain how my visuals help show the relationship among power, resistance, and cultural continuity.
  • I can use some digital media or visual displays to support my ideas and include evidence from sources, but my explanations may not fully connect the visuals to the historical argument or to present-day organizing challenges
  • I can communicate a clear main idea with guidance and revise my work after feedback to improve accuracy, clarity, and audience fit.
  • I can strategically choose digital media or visual displays that strengthen my explanation of evidence and help audiences understand the historical connections among systems of power, resistance, and community action
  • I can compare multiple perspectives, use relevant source evidence, and revise my exhibit labels or interpretive brief to make my reasoning clearer, more accurate, and more useful for the intended audience.
  • I can make highly effective use of digital media or visual displays to deepen understanding, engage my audience, and present a persuasive, well-supported interpretation that fuses multiple sources and perspectives
  • I can justify my design choices, connect the past to the present with precision, and use peer and partner feedback to refine my work so it is accurate, accessible, and powerful for both the Schomburg Center and BYP100.
New York
VA:Pr6.1.HSII.a - Make, explain, and justify connections between artists or artwork and social, cultural, and political history.
  • I can identify and describe a connection between an artwork or cultural artifact and a historical context when the connection is directly shown in the evidence, even if my explanation is brief or partly incomplete
  • I can name at least one source and use it to begin explaining how power or resistance appears in the historical setting.
  • I can explain a clear connection between an artwork or cultural artifact and social, cultural, or political history using relevant evidence from more than one source
  • I can describe the source’s perspective or limitation and use visual or digital elements that help an audience follow my main idea.
  • I can analyze and justify multiple connections between an artwork or cultural artifact and the broader historical forces shaping it, using corroborated evidence and recognizing more than one perspective
  • I can create a coherent public-facing product that is accurate, audience-appropriate, and supported by citations, visuals, and reasoning.
  • I can make a nuanced, persuasive interpretation of how an artwork or cultural artifact reflects and shapes social, cultural, and political history, synthesizing diverse evidence and perspectives with a strong warrant
  • I can evaluate the effect of my presentation on the audience, revise strategically from feedback, and communicate my conclusions with clarity, precision, and impact.
New York
C.9-12.2 - Identify, compare, and evaluate multiple perspectives on a given historical experience.
  • I can identify at least one perspective in the historical evidence and the present-day organizing challenge, but my explanation may be incomplete, mostly descriptive, or based on a limited set of sources
  • I may need support to compare viewpoints, connect evidence to the challenge question, and explain how the sources shape my understanding.
  • I can compare multiple perspectives on the historical experience and the BYP100 challenge using some relevant evidence, and I can explain key similarities or differences with general clarity
  • I am beginning to evaluate source credibility, limitations, and missing viewpoints, and I can use feedback to improve my claim and communication.
  • I can compare and evaluate multiple perspectives using diverse, relevant evidence from primary and secondary sources, and I can explain how each perspective supports or complicates my historical understanding
  • I can connect historical circumstances to present-day organizing barriers with clear reasoning, and I can revise my work based on peer or partner feedback for accuracy, clarity, and audience fit.
  • I can thoroughly compare and evaluate multiple perspectives, synthesize strong evidence into a persuasive interpretation, and explain how economic, political, legal, and cultural forces shape both the historical experience and the current organizing challenge
  • I can use evidence, visuals, and clear communication to address counterpoints, justify a practical recommendation, and revise my work thoughtfully for an authentic audience.
New York
VA:Pr6.1.HSI.a - Analyze and describe the effect that an exhibition or collection has on personal awareness of social, cultural, or political beliefs and understandings.
  • I can identify a few relevant details from sources and describe a simple connection between an exhibit or collection and social, cultural, or political history, but my explanation may be general, incomplete, or rely on one perspective
  • I can use limited evidence and basic visuals or media with partial clarity, and I may need significant support to explain how the exhibit changed my understanding.
  • I can analyze several relevant sources to describe how an exhibit or collection shapes my awareness of social, cultural, or political beliefs and understandings
  • I can connect at least one piece of evidence to a historical idea, include some visual or digital media to support my message, and explain my thinking with mostly clear organization and audience awareness.
  • I can analyze and describe how a set of sources and an exhibit or collection deepen my awareness of social, cultural, or political beliefs and understandings, using accurate evidence from more than one perspective
  • I can make clear connections between the historical evidence and my interpretation, use digital media or visual displays strategically, and explain how the sources influenced my thinking.
  • I can thoroughly analyze and describe how an exhibit or collection changes and deepens my awareness of social, cultural, or political beliefs and understandings, using well-chosen evidence from diverse sources and multiple perspectives
  • I can justify my interpretation with clear reasoning, use digital media or visual displays to strengthen understanding and audience engagement, and communicate a nuanced, accurate, and persuasive explanation independently.
New York
11.5.b - Rapid industrialization and urbanization created significant challenges and societal problems that were addressed by a variety of reform efforts.
  • I can identify a basic historical issue about how rapid industrialization and urbanization created social problems, but my connections may be general, incomplete, or only partly supported by source evidence
  • I can name at least one source and one idea from it, though I may need significant support to explain why the evidence matters or how it connects to the present.
  • I can describe how industrialization and urbanization created challenges and explain them with some relevant evidence from diverse sources
  • I can make a clear but developing connection between evidence, multiple perspectives, and a present-day organizing or community issue, though my argument or exhibit may still have gaps in accuracy, depth, or audience fit.
  • I can analyze and compare diverse sources to explain how interconnected economic, political, legal, and cultural forces shaped social problems and reform responses in a historical context
  • I can build a defensible argument or exhibit label set that uses cited evidence, considers multiple perspectives, and makes a clear connection to present-day collective action, with only minor errors or omissions.
  • I can synthesize strong, relevant evidence from multiple diverse sources to construct a persuasive, nuanced understanding of how linked systems of power produce social problems and how people resist and reform them
  • I can justify my interpretations with precise reasoning, engage multiple perspectives, use digital or visual media strategically, and revise my work effectively for clarity, accuracy, accessibility, and audience impact.
New York
C.9-12.6 - Connect historical developments to specific circumstances of time and place and to broader regional, national, or global processes and draw connections to the present (where appropriate).
  • I can identify a few relevant historical developments and present-day barriers, but my connections across time and place are partial or mostly descriptive
  • I use limited source evidence, with some references to context, perspective, or audience, but my explanation of how specific economic, political, legal, and cultural forces shape events is still emerging.
  • I can explain historical developments with clear time-and-place connections and use more than one source to compare evidence, perspectives, and limitations
  • I make a basic present-day connection and begin to show how systems of power reinforce one another, though my claim, reasoning, or recommendation may still need greater depth or precision.
  • I can connect historical developments to their specific historical context and to broader processes, using varied evidence to compare perspectives and support a plausible argument
  • I explain how interconnected systems of power shaped both historical and present-day barriers, and I include a practical recommendation that is mostly clear, relevant, and supported by sources.
  • I can synthesize diverse, credible evidence into a persuasive interpretation that clearly connects historical developments to time, place, broader processes, and the present
  • I evaluate multiple perspectives and source limitations, make strategic use of visual or digital media, and present a nuanced, well-supported recommendation that is clear, audience-centered, and actionable.
New York
11.10.a - After World War II, long-term demands for equality by African Americans led to the civil rights movement. The efforts of individuals, groups, and institutions helped to redefine African American civil rights, though numerous issues remain unresolved.
  • I can identify a few relevant historical sources and repeat simple details about how African Americans faced racial violence and exclusion after Reconstruction, but my labels or brief may include general claims, few connections between sources, or limited evidence about power, resistance, and cultural continuity
  • I may need support to choose accurate examples, explain present-day connections, and respond to feedback.
  • I can use several sources to explain basic links among economic, political, legal, and cultural forces and describe at least one similarity between historical barriers and a current organizing challenge
  • My exhibit labels or interpretive brief include some evidence, but the reasoning, comparisons, and audience fit may still be uneven, and I may revise with help to improve clarity and accuracy.
  • I can combine evidence from diverse sources to compare multiple perspectives on barriers African Americans faced between Reconstruction and the Harlem Renaissance and barriers in current NYC organizing
  • My labels or brief make a clear claim, explain connections among power and resistance, and use visuals or digital media purposefully, though some reasoning, citation, or recommendation details may still need refinement after feedback.
  • I can synthesize compelling evidence from diverse sources to create an accurate, audience-centered exhibit label set and interpretive brief that clearly connects historical systems of power, resistance, and cultural continuity to present-day organizing challenges
  • I can evaluate source credibility and limits, acknowledge multiple perspectives, justify a practical recommendation with strong reasoning, and revise my work independently based on feedback.
New York
A.9-12.6 - Deconstruct and construct plausible and persuasive arguments, using evidence.
  • I can identify a historical claim and select a few pieces of source evidence, but my explanation may be mostly descriptive or list facts without clearly showing how the evidence supports the claim
  • I can name at least one barrier or form of resistance, though my reasoning may be incomplete and I may need support to connect it to the larger system of power or the present-day challenge.
  • I can construct a clear claim about how systems of power and resistance work, and I can support it with relevant evidence from more than one source
  • I can describe different perspectives or limitations in the sources, and I can make some connections between the historical evidence and BYP100’s organizing challenge, though my argument may not yet fully explain the relationship among them.
  • I can deconstruct a historical issue into connected economic, political, legal, and cultural parts, then build a persuasive argument that uses multiple credible sources to explain how those parts reinforced one another
  • I can compare perspectives, address limitations or counterevidence, and connect the past to the present in a way that is clear, audience-aware, and supported by visual or digital choices that strengthen understanding.
  • I can synthesize diverse primary and secondary evidence into a nuanced, persuasive argument that explains how systems of power endure and how people resist by disrupting their connections
  • I can integrate multiple perspectives, evaluate credibility and silences, address counterarguments fairly, and present a polished exhibit label set and interpretive brief that are accurate, accessible, visually effective, and actionable for the intended audiences.