9th Grade  Project 4 weeks

Bots & Brushes Bash

Sarah F
Updated
VA:Cr2.2.HSI.a
VA:Cr3.1.HSI.a
VA:Cr3.1.HSII.a
VA:Cr3.1.HSIII.a
Art and community
+ 4 more
1-pager

The Challenge

In NYC and other dense transit systems, unclear wayfinding and heavy foot traffic make movement through stations slow, confusing, and unsafe, especially during peak travel times. When people cannot quickly interpret signs and spatial cues, crowding increases, delays ripple across the system, and public spaces become harder to navigate equitably.

Challenge Question

How might we use robotics-inspired movement thinking and community art to design clearer, more engaging subway wayfinding that helps NYC riders move through crowded stations with less confusion? Students will investigate how the way we make things matters as much as what we make by studying rider flow, revising ideas through critique, and using environmentally conscious art-making practices. Their solution will take the form of a before-and-after station flow map, a signage proposal, and a short presentation for feedback from an authentic audience such as MTA Arts & Design.

Standards
  • [New York] VA:Cr2.2.HSI.a - Demonstrate an environmentally conscious approach to conservation, care, and clean-up of art materials, tools, and equipment in the art classroom.
  • [New York] VA:Cr3.1.HSI.a - Apply relevant criteria and the feedback of others to revise and refine works of art and design in progress.
  • [New York] VA:Cr3.1.HSII.a - Engage in constructive critique with peers; then reflect on, re-engage, revise, and refine works of art and design in response to personal artistic vision.
  • [New York] VA:Cr3.1.HSIII.a - Reflect on, re-engage, revise, and artwork refine works of art or design considering relevant traditional and contemporary criteria as well as personal artistic vision.
Competencies
  • Artistic Expression - Art and community (FK.AC.1.c)
  • Artistic Expression - Making art (FK.AC.1.b)
  • Art Analysis - Art and society (FK.AC.2.c)
  • Artistic Expression - Power of art (FK.AC.1.a)
  • Sharing Ideas - Seeking feedback (OT.Creat.2.a)

Learning Partners and Clients

MTA Arts & Design in New York City could serve as the primary learning partner and client by reviewing student prototypes for subway-facing signage and wayfinding concepts tied to rider movement and station clarity. Students can also look to NYC subway riders as an authentic public audience whose movement patterns, confusion points, and feedback shape the before-and-after station flow maps and signage proposals. These partners connect directly to the project’s real-world challenge and give students a concrete audience for critique, revision, and presentation.

Phase Outcomes

Phase Learning Outcome
Discover
I can experience a simulated crowded subway station, notice where movement becomes confusing, and identify root causes of rider frustration by observing traffic flow, unclear signage, and space bottlenecks.
Examine
I can document how people move through a station-like space and identify patterns that cause crowding and confusion. I can analyze examples of subway signage, community art, and wayfinding systems to explain how visual choices affect movement and understanding. I can gather peer feedback and use critique to determine which design features make public art and signage more clear, helpful, and responsive to community needs. I can investigate how environmentally conscious material choices, care, and clean-up practices matter when creating art for shared public spaces.
Engineer
I can develop a before-and-after station flow map and a community-centered signage proposal that uses visual design, artistic expression, and environmentally conscious material choices to improve clarity and reduce crowding for NYC subway riders.
Do
I can place my wayfinding prototype into a simulated rider pathway, collect observation notes and user feedback on how clearly people move through the space, and use that data to judge how well my solution reduces confusion and crowding.
Share
I can share my station flow map, signage proposal, critique revisions, and personal reflections in an interactive presentation for classmates, families, school staff, and NYC-connected arts or transit partners, explaining how my ideas changed through feedback and what I learned about myself as an artist, collaborator, and problem-solver.