Knowledge/Skill Building

🧩 Belonging Evidence Cluster Map

Competencies Content Expertise Critical Thinking & Problem Solving Effective Communication Collaboration Academic Mindset

Standards CCSS.ELA-Literacy.WHST.6-8.5 CCSS.ELA-Literacy.SL.8.1 CCSS.ELA-Literacy.WHST.6-8.7 CCSS.ELA-Literacy.W.8.7

Elements Assessment Reflection Core Content Project Launch Essential Question

Settings Submission Required

Students bring forward notes from the Story Snapshots Mixer, short story annotations, and at least one real user insight from Phase 1, then work in small groups to sort them on chart paper or a digital whiteboard into themes such as welcome, exclusion, identity, and voice. The teacher models how to separate observations from assumptions and how to trace a pattern back to quoted story details or interview notes. Each group creates a labeled cluster map and drafts one evidence-based need statement about belonging.

Plan day

Day 3

Duration

45 min

Grouping

Small Group

Steps

7 steps

Lesson plan

7 steps · 45 min

#	What teachers do	Time
1	Launch the task by posting the essential question, naming the goal of building an evidence cluster map, and having students quickly gather three source types: Story Snapshots Mixer sticky notes, short story annotations, and at least one Phase 1 user insight.	5 min
2	Model the process with 3-4 sample notes: read each note aloud, sort it as observation or assumption, and show how to anchor a claim in quoted story details or interview notes before placing it into a theme such as welcome, exclusion, identity, or voice.	7 min
3	Place students in small groups of 3-4 and have them spread out all evidence on chart paper or a digital whiteboard, silently sort notes into possible theme clusters, and mark any note that needs stronger proof with a question mark.	8 min
4	Have groups discuss their sort, rename or combine clusters, and justify each category using direct text evidence or user notes while one student records cluster labels and another tracks cited details under each group of evidence.	10 min
5	Guide groups to identify one repeated pattern across sources and draft one evidence-based need statement about belonging using a frame such as 'Students/people need ___ because evidence shows ___.', making sure the statement is based on observations rather than assumptions.	7 min
6	Facilitate a quick share-out in which each group presents its strongest cluster and need statement, then invite one peer question or suggestion that pushes for clearer evidence, stronger wording, or a more precise pattern.	5 min
7	Close by having students add their names to the cluster map, save or post the final product for reuse in the next activity, and complete a brief exit reflection naming one pattern they now see about how belonging is defined.	3 min
	Total	45 mins

Preparation (7 items)

Prepare grouped sets of student evidence sources: Story Snapshots Mixer sticky notes or photos, annotated short story excerpts, and Phase 1 user insight notes so each group has access to multiple source types.
Set up one chart paper sheet or shared digital whiteboard per group with space for cluster labels, cited evidence, and a final need statement.
Pre-write the essential question and sample theme headings such as welcome, exclusion, identity, and voice where all students can see them.
Select 3-4 sample notes from class materials to model the difference between observation and assumption and to demonstrate how to cite a quote or interview detail.
Prepare markers, sticky notes, tape, sentence stems for discussion and need statements, and a simple color-coding key for literary evidence versus user insight.
Arrange groups of 3-4 in advance with attention to balanced participation, reading support, and discussion dynamics.
Create a quick exit reflection prompt students can complete in writing before leaving: 'One pattern I see about belonging is ___ because ___.'.

Student-facing instructions

You will work with a small group to organize evidence about belonging from three sources: your Story Snapshots Mixer notes, your short story annotations, and at least one real user insight from Phase 1. Your materials are your notes, annotated text, chart paper or a digital whiteboard, markers or sticky notes, and the need statement sentence frame. First, you will sort your evidence into possible theme clusters such as welcome, exclusion, identity, and voice. As you sort, your task is to separate observations from assumptions and support your ideas with a quoted story detail or an interview note whenever possible. Then you will label your clusters, identify one repeated pattern across sources, and write one evidence-based need statement about belonging. Your goal is to create a clear visual map that shows how you define belonging using real evidence and that will help you in the next activity when you write a How Might We statement.

Success criteria

You are successful when your group has: (1) used evidence from all three source types; (2) created at least three clearly labeled clusters related to belonging; (3) included specific text details or user notes to support each cluster; (4) identified at least one note that was an assumption and revised or removed it; (5) written one evidence-based need statement that names a real pattern rather than a guess; and (6) explained your cluster map to peers with each group member contributing at least once.

Facilitator notes

Keep the pacing tight so most of the time is spent on student talk and evidence handling rather than whole-group explanation. Adolescents tend to jump quickly to opinions, so repeatedly prompt: 'What did you actually notice?' and 'What evidence shows that?' If groups struggle, offer sentence stems such as 'This belongs in ___ because the text says ___' or 'This may be an assumption because ___.' Encourage students to reuse launch sticky notes so they see continuity from the Story Snapshots Mixer into this Define phase. Watch for clusters that are too broad; push groups to rename vague categories like 'feelings' into more precise ideas such as exclusion or voice. For students needing support, provide pre-sorted starter categories, highlighted quotes, or a reduced number of notes. For students ready for more challenge, ask them to split one large cluster into sub-patterns or compare how belonging is shown differently in literary evidence versus user insight. Make sure one student does not dominate the sorting; assign rotating roles such as sorter, evidence checker, recorder, and speaker if needed. Save all maps visibly or digitally because students will need them for the next How Might We Belonging Statement activity and later pair-share reflection circles.

Resources

No resources yet