🔍 HMW Evidence Critique Protocol

In critique groups of 3–4, students present their POV and primary HMW question. Peers use a structured protocol: (1) identify where user evidence is strong, (2) flag assumptions not grounded in quotes or data, and (3) test whether the HMW is appropriately scoped. Each student gives feedback to two peers and receives feedback from at least two peers, then revises their HMW and submits a final version before leaving.